Our technology thoroughly searches through the online shopping world, reviewing hundreds of sites. We then process and analyze this information, updating in real-time to bring you the latest top-rated products. This way, you always get the best and most current options available.

Winner
The Amazon Basics Fireproof Safe offers strong protection for home valuables with a certified fire rating that can withstand 1 hour at 1700°F, which is solid for typical residential fire scenarios. Its waterproof feature is impressive too, providing up to 24 hours of protection even when submerged 8 inches deep, ensuring your documents and items are safe from water damage. The safe’s 2.13 cubic feet capacity is spacious enough for important papers, small electronics, and jewelry, and it includes a removable shelf and drawer for better organization.
Security is enhanced by a preset digital electronic lock combined with six live-locking bolts and pry-resistant dead bolts, offering a reliable defense against break-ins. The heavy-duty alloy steel construction adds durability, and the interior light is a handy bonus for visibility. It also comes with bolt-down hardware to secure the safe to the floor, reducing theft risk.
The safe is quite heavy at about 136 pounds, which might make it difficult to move without help. It requires batteries for the electronic lock, which aren’t included, so you’ll need to purchase them separately. The 1-year limited warranty is standard but relatively short compared to some competitors. This safe is well suited for homeowners seeking a solid, fireproof and waterproof safe with good size and security features, though it’s more appropriate for stationary use due to its weight.
The Steelwater Gun Safe model AMLD593924-EMP is a heavy-duty, fireproof safe designed primarily for gun owners looking to secure a large collection of firearms. It boasts a 60-minute fire protection rating, which is crucial for fire safety. With a capacity of up to 39 long guns, though realistically accommodating 24-30, it is spacious enough for avid collectors. The safe's construction includes 20 solid steel locking bolts and an 8x larger drill/ballistic resistant hard plate, enhancing its security features significantly.
Additionally, the EMP-proof keypad and high-security bypass key add layers of protection against unauthorized access and electromagnetic pulse attacks. The dehumidifier and automatic LED interior lighting are valuable extras, ensuring your items remain in good condition and easy to access in low light. The interior is well-designed with adjustable shelves and a door organizer, providing flexible storage options.
However, the safe is quite heavy at 689 pounds, which may pose challenges during installation. It's also water-resistant rather than fully waterproof, which might be a drawback for users in flood-prone areas. The electronic combination lock requires batteries, which is another maintenance point to consider. This safe is a solid choice for users needing robust fire and theft protection for firearms but may be overkill for those with smaller storage needs or less concern about fire and EMP threats.
The Honeywell 2609 safe is a sturdy and reliable option for protecting valuables at home, especially if you want both fire and water protection. It offers a solid 2-hour fire resistance, which is good for most home fire emergencies, helping keep your important documents and items safe from heat damage. One standout feature is its full submersible waterproof rating for 8 hours, meaning it can protect contents even in flooding, which is rare in many fireproof safes.
The safe is built from heavy-duty alloy steel and includes strong locking bolts, giving it a robust physical defense. Security is enhanced with a digital keypad lock, an anti-theft alarm, and two emergency keys, making it easy to access yet well-guarded against unauthorized entry. Inside, the safe provides a decent 2.39 cubic feet of space with two shelves, allowing organized storage for cash, media, or small valuables. It weighs 214 pounds, which adds to its security but means it’s meant to be installed in a fixed spot using the included floor mounting kit.
It uses 4 AA batteries for the keypad, so periodic battery replacement is necessary. This safe is well-suited for homeowners seeking a robust, fire and flood-resistant solution with convenient digital access and solid storage capacity.